Research Article Critique
Select one research article (related to your selected topic). Complete a research article critique in APA format. Be sure to review the rubric for this assignment (here in Canvas) before starting this assignment.
Rubric
Research Article Critique Rubric
Research Article Critique Rubric
CriteriaRatingsPts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentify the purpose statement
5 pts
Exceeds Expectations
3.75 pts
Meets Expectations
2.5 pts
Below Expectations
1.25 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
5 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentify the population of interest
5 pts
Exceeds Expectations
3.75 pts
Meets Expectations
2.5 pts
Below Expectations
1.25 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
5 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentify the study variables
5 pts
Exceeds Expectations
3.75 pts
Meets Expectations
2.5 pts
Below Expectations
1.25 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
5 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeClassify study variables as Correlational, Independent, Dependent, or Extraneous; Classify level of measurement of study variables
15 pts
Exceeds Expectations
11.25 pts
Meets Expectations
7.5 pts
Below Expectations
3.75 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
15 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentify the Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria and the resulting sample element (subject)
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentify the operationalized population of interest and critique validity
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeDescribe the sampling method used and classify it. (Ex. convenience, random or nonrandom, etc.) Discuss the appropriateness and limitations of the sampling method
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentify the study design and time perspective
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeAnalyze the usefulness/completeness/clarity of the methods section. (Do you understand what was done in the study? Are there problems with it?)
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSummarize and analyze the results including basic statistics. (How were the study findings reported? Were summary statistics reported appropriately and extraneous variables addressed and “controlled� How clear was the reporting?)
20 pts
Exceeds Expectations
15 pts
Meets Expectations
10 pts
Below Expectations
5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
20 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeAnalyze the discussion. Was it in keeping with the reporting of the finding? Were positive and negative findings discussed? Was power discussed? Was it appropriate?
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSummarize the author’s conclusion. What they think, not what you think.
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeGive your informed and reasoned opinion about the conclusion of the research. Would you recommend any changes in patient care or nursing practice as a result of this study?
10 pts
Exceeds Expectations
7.5 pts
Meets Expectations
5 pts
Below Expectations
2.5 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
10 pts
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSummarize the Research
15 pts
Exceeds Expectations
11.25 pts
Meets Expectations
7.5 pts
Below Expectations
3.75 pts
Did not Meet Expectations
0 pts
Did not Include
15 pts
